Skip to content
1

Therasense Makes No Sense–Federal Circuit Grants En Banc Review of Inequitable Conduct

Therasense Makes No Sense–Federal Circuit Grants En Banc Review of Inequitable Conduct

In practice, requiring patent attorneys to disclose any contradictory arguments made in any related patent application is unduly burdensome on applicants. While we certainly do not want to invite applicants to make contradictory arguments, invalidating a patent due to a contradictory attorney argument is a harsh result, particularly if there is no direct evidence of intent to deceive or if the failure to disclose would have made no difference in the examiner’s decision to allow the application. Thus, the Federal Circuit’s decision in Therasense makes no sense and should be brought in line with the realities of everyday patent prosecution by requiring proof of causation.

Read & Discuss »

Browse by Category

Patents

Promises Not to Challenge the Validity of a Patent after MedImmune: Are they Enforceable?

Promises Not to Challenge the Validity of a Patent after MedImmune:  Are they Enforceable?

In MedImmune, Inc. v. Genentech, Inc., 549 U.S. 118, 127 S. Ct. 764 (2007), the Supreme Court held that a licensee had standing to challenge the validity of the licensed patent, despite the licensee’s failure to breach the agreement by refusing to pay royalties.  In the wake of this opinion, there was much debate about [...]

Read More & Discuss »
How to Pay Me Less Money for a Patent Application

How to Pay Me Less Money for a Patent Application

No Comments
Round 4: Patent Reform Act of 2009 Introduced in Congress

Round 4: Patent Reform Act of 2009 Introduced in Congress

No Comments
More from Patents »

Copyrights

World of Warcraft Meets the Digital Millenium Copyright Act

World of Warcraft Meets the Digital Millenium Copyright Act

The Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) was enacted by Congress in 1998 in part to prevent the circumvention of technological measures designed to prevent either access to or copying of a copyrighted work. With certain exceptions, the DMCA made it a crime to circumvent such measures and outlawed the manufacture, sale, or distribution of devices used to illegally copy software.

Examples of such anti-piracy prevention measures include technology that prevents an unauthorized copy of a DVD from being played and software that limits the number of times a computer program can be installed. Because the law is relatively new and because technology is constantly changing, the scope and application of the DMCA remains an evolving frontier.

Read More & Discuss »
More from Copyrights »

Trademarks, Trade Dress, and Unfair Competition

Hall of Famer Jim Brown Fails to Break Through Electronic Arts’ First Amendment Defense

Hall of Famer Jim Brown Fails to Break Through Electronic Arts’ First Amendment Defense

 

Judge Florence-Marie Cooper of the Central District of California recently dismissed Jim Brown’s claim of false endorsement against Electronic Arts.  The decision continues the courts’ trend of finding that the First Amendment provides a complete defense to a claim of unfair competition when source identifiers are used within video games.
Jim Brown is a retired professional [...]

Read More & Discuss »
Remember the Alamo:  Federal Trademark Dilution v. Texas Trademark Dilution

Remember the Alamo: Federal Trademark Dilution v. Texas Trademark Dilution

No Comments
More from Trademarks, Trade Dress, and Unfair Competition »

Business of IP

Leveling the IP Field for Minorities: Why A Game Driven by Creativity is Worth Playing

Leveling the IP Field for Minorities:  Why A Game Driven by Creativity is Worth Playing

 Note: This article is from a guest contributor, Celina Diaz, an associate at Carstens & Cahoon. Ms. Diaz is a native Texan, born in Corpus Christi after her parents moved from Peru. Ms. Diaz majored in both Chemistry and Spanish Civilizations at the University of Texas at Austin, while taking pre-medical courses. She studied in [...]

Read More & Discuss »
Corporate Legal Departments Turn to Boutique Law Firms

Corporate Legal Departments Turn to Boutique Law Firms

No Comments
More from Business of IP »